Sunday, May 18, 2014

Rolling The Dice: Gacha Probabilities

What Are Our Chances of Winning a 5-Star Ranger?

We all take a chance with our rubies hoping to play the GACHA machine for great rangers like KSM, Sorcerer Cony, etc. The vast majority of us have experienced our fair share of disappointment with this random generator. I read an article today where the author, 楊濟安, has taken the effort to crunch the numbers on exactly what our odds are of landing a 4 or 5 star ranger. His calculations are based on a healthy sampling from a couple hundred volunteers who shared their Gacha results. The full article goes into detail so if your Chinese (and curiosity of probability) is solid, do go and read the whole thing. Again, full credit goes to the author of the article, but I will pull a few details to discuss here for the benefit of our English speaking community. It's a burning question that we all want to know about because some of us (many of us) spend cold, hard cash and we would like to know just how much of a gamble it is.
So if you're not interested in all the gritty details (TL;DR and all that), during the "Double Chance on 5 Star" event, the probability of getting a 5-star ranger  is approximately 20%. The probability for 4-star is approximately 30% and 3 star is about 49-50%, based upon the samples obtained. Based on this, the probability of 5-star rangers goes down to only 10% when the event is not taking place. 

Other Interesting Findings

One of the assumptions that he takes on is that every turn of the Gacha is an independent event. This means that one turn of the Gacha has no bearing on the result of the next turn of the Gacha. He believes that the 6 results from 100 rubies Gacha are independent events because a lot of people reported getting four 4-stars and one 5-star, or three 5-stars and three 4-stars. This kind of result would not be possible if the game developer had set the 100 rubies Gacha to be dependent events. For instance, if we believe the Gacha is set up to predetermined dependent results, then we should often get results of three 3-stars, two 4-stars and one 5-star, with some variability but not to the extreme of some people getting four or five 4-star rangers in one shot of 100 rubies. I buy his line of reasoning for this assumption, and it is an important one to make.

The author imparts us with a bit of basic probability knowledge which may affect the way we interpret the possible results we get when we play. Suppose there were 10 marbles in a can and one of the marbles would win you a prize. 10 people line up to pick out one marble each, one at a time. Each time someone picks a marble, they put the marble back. The chances of each person winning the prize is 1 out of 10 -- easy, of course. Suppose the 10 people in line picked out a marble each and did not put their marble back after selecting. Now who has the highest probability of winning the prize? The answer is they all still have the same chance of winning, which is 1 out of 10. (The first person has a 1/10 chance he has picked the winning marble. The second person has a 9/10 chance that the first person didn't get the winning marble * 1/10 chance that he selected the winning marble = 1/10). All this is to say that the misconception that if you got something good from the Gacha, the chances of you getting something good again the next turn is lessened, is completely mathematically false. If the chance of getting a 5 star ranger is set by the game developer at 10%, then your chances each and every time you play the Gacha is 10%, no matter what you got in the past, no matter what someone you know recently got, no matter night or day or where you live. The numbers don't lie :)

Six 3-star rangers? Sad day.
Another question he answered was regarding the poor players who get six 3-star rangers with 100 rubies. How is this possible in a world where the chance to get a 3-star ranger one time is 50%? He uses normal probability distributions to determine that there is a 81.33% probability of not obtaining six 3-stars. If you happened to be the chap who got six 3-stars, you're in the unlucky 18.67% lot. It's not an insignificant chance if you ask me!

One last note is, he made some assumptions to show that playing 100 rubies at a time is only slightly better than playing 20 rubies at a time but the details are a bit fuzzy to me (lost in translation; I couldn't quite understand the assumptions he made to arrive at his numbers). All I can say is that he concluded that the overall result of doing 20 rubies 5 times versus 100 rubies 1 time, that the 100 rubies wins out, if only by a little. 

The article was really enlightening and fascinating. Might takes maybe a bit of knowledge in statistics and a lot of Chinese to understand, but totally awesome that someone took the time to not only crunch numbers but also explain all this stuff. Bravo and a big thank you to 楊濟安 and the people who shared their results to make this study possible. In the words of Bill Nye the Science Guy, "now you know!"
I know what you're thinking! You're thinking, 20%? Pfffltt. Screw that, I didn't get anything from my rubies! I got Lucas, Hunt, Vlad, Ryan and Jason over and over! Remember that's 20% overall in a relatively large sample pool. If you played the Gacha 100 times in a row, 20 rubies at a time, surely close to 20 of them will be 5-stars. 

I'll give you an example. I found out from my Macho Moon Friendship Point Event study that the chance to get Macho Moon during this event was in the neighborhood of 4%. However as it so happens on day one of the event, I played the Friendship Gacha 172 times before I got my very first Macho Moon. That translates to 0.6% in a sample of 172. Not even one percent! It seemed absurd to me at the time. But later on in the day as I continued to play, oddly enough, I got Macho Moon 2 out of 3 spins, which is 66.6% looking at a sample of 3. On day one I played the Gacha a total of 244 times and landed myself 10 Macho Moons. So it evened itself out to 4.1%. Day two and day three were not nearly as dramatic because Moon popped out much more evenly. But throughout the course of the day I did find myself inexplicably caught in chains of 1 and 2 stars, then later on, in chains of 3-stars. However, even the 1, 2 and 3 star quantities leveled themselves out if I played enough times in a day. This is just how statistics and probability goes. We arrive at a number that is the result of calculations from an extremely large amount of trials. Your reality after playing a handful of times may vary quite a lot from the average.

And let's not forget that the 20% is not the chance that you will get something useful to you. The 20% emcompasses the chances that you will get duds like Luke (who nobody wants lol), Xan, Sol and Alice (who are available from stage clear rolls). The chances of you getting what you want (like KSM, Dancer King Boss, Sorcerer Cony and the like), is actually quite a bit smaller. So let's not confuse what you want with the total probability of 5-star rangers. 

[Addendum: I emailed the company and asked them whether the probability of all rangers within the same star grade is the same throughout. I have been told that the probability of all the rangers is preset. They do discriminate among the rangers as they deem some rarer than others, and the rarer ones have a lower probability than the others. Therefore, while the general odds of getting 5-star rangers on a normal day may be 10%, within the 10% there is another variable which determines which 5-star ranger you'll get. We can safely assume that the more desirable rangers are the "rarer" ones they referenced. However, a smaller chance does not mean no chance, it is just less probable. It's like they say in the lottery business: You have to play to win. And if you don't ever Gacha, then you will never win. If you don't want to gamble, that's your decision. So that's it, I'll leave it at that!]

Hope this post was helpful to you guys out there! Happy gaming and good luck!

Thursday, May 15, 2014

Skyscraper - Videos and Thoughts

Skyscraper: Monkey brains, bats, ladybugs, dynamite... and twerking. What's not to love?
Although I don't think I like the poodle abusing goth chick.

[Update: May 21, 2014] 
Skyscraper has been revised. The boss stages are more difficult than they were at the initial release.

As some sort of consolation for making the area more challenging, LINE has sent us all a free Cobe. I like Cobe, but, I think it's still generally a bad idea to make stages more difficult after they have been released. That's just my personal opinion on game updates, though. I suppose it'll put players without special rangers in an even more precarious position for stage progression, and those with KSM & company may wince maybe a little at the change. Cobe may help, but probably not a ton. Cobe is a good splash ranger who can get herself (himself?) up to the front line fairly quickly and can take a few hits due to medium-high HP at max level. I believe this is the second free Cobe event since the launch of the game, so veteran players may have a level 60 Cobe already.

The New Stuff

The newly available 4 star ranger is Opera James and 5 star is Masked Moon. James is absolutely fantastic as he's a powerful splash ranger who costs less than Clara and maxes out at higher damage as well. Masked Moon at level is quite a piece of work. I personally haven't found a good reason to use him yet but at max, his health is insane and his attack is formidable. At lower levels, I would pass on him altogether because you have better options for both health and attack.

And the Treasure for this area is... click to find out!

Free Ranger Videos (Up to date)

First-time Playthrough Links 

I used Hip Hop Brown [70], KSM [55], Dancer King Boss [60], Sorcerer Cony [50], Charismatic Jessica [70] in almost all of these first attempts... just because I can. These videos were just for fun because I recorded the very first time I encountered the new stages. If you are looking for other ranger teams, I might work on those later, though there are plenty of people who do a better job of those kinds of videos than I do! I make no claims about being a good player, I just try my best with what I have, so proceed with the attitude of fun, please. [Update: All the boss stages were revised to be more difficult, featuring more mini boss enemies per stage. Videos are probably outdated but haven't had time to sort it all out so watch with caution.]

Stage 117 pwnd (me)
Stage 117 Cleared
Stage 118 Cleared

Stage 112 Cleared (Free rangers: Sol, Clara, Sindy, Warrior Jessica, Scott) - [Update: outdated due to stage revision]

First Impressions

I stand corrected on my previous predictions. This entire zone was trivialized significantly by KSM, Dancer King, Hip Hop and Bernard. If you watched my videos above, this is quite obvious. Every stage was one-shot except for 117 & 120. I got 120 on my 4th try (with Dancer King [60], Sorcerer Cony [50] and 3 lowbies). I still enjoyed it, though. Going back and trying these again with other ranger combinations will be fun.
Mundo? More like Psycho... Pet kidnapper. I don't like her. I bet she's the one who abducted Sally for the Alien King.
In addition, lowbies have made a huge comeback. I will try my best to remember to put KSM & company back in my team when I am not playing, sorry in advance if you use my help and get a Bella :( Koji (red jumpsuit enemy) is really terrible to deal with and having a horde of lowbies in the front helps a lot. Same with the dynamite enemies (not listed in the enemy collection). It's also very helpful on Stage 120 where Mundo (poodle riding boss) body slams everything in a huge radius. Might as well let her kill throwaway lowbies. 

Richard, the green dino mini boss, has an insane range. I mean, really ridiculously long range. Everything, including Dancer King Boss and probably most towers, gets hit by his splash damage. Any time this mini boss is present, it acts as a ticking time bomb because if you don't kill him in time, your tower will get splashed down and game over -- Use your Tower Repair carefully. Luckily, his attack speed is pretty slow, and he's not terribly difficult to block with a standard health ranger.

That's all the thoughts I have for now. Hope everyone is enjoying the new area's challenges.

Tuesday, May 13, 2014

Friendship Point Event - Macho Moon



Macho Moon is now in the mix of Friendship Point GACHA for the next 7 days. The only difference between this event and the Clara event is that Friendship Points remain at 20 points for sending and receiving help (no event-only boost to 50 pts). If someone selects your rangers as help for a stage, you get 10 points, as always.

Now's the time! Gather up your friends and try your chance at getting Macho Moon. Here is the Friend ID sharing page where you can add loads of friends, and feel free to add yourself to the list, too. Be sure you go to LINE app> Settings > Profile and tick "Public User ID" to allow people to add you.

I've had terrible, terrible odds so far during this event, but it's only Day 1. I hear others are getting Macho Moon rather quickly. Let's all help each other win level 60 Macho Moon! Remember, you'll need 5 to get him to maximum level capacity. 356K HP at level 60 with a 310 mineral cost is not too shabby at all.
A handsome, nice fellow who likes to live dangerously. And so deliciously plump at max level. 
Just when I was lamenting about how going forward I would have to use Xan or Styne as the health ranger standard to do free ranger videos, this event comes to save the day. Macho Moon is my preferred health ranger when I need someone with loads of HP. He walks faster than Brown and Styne by a mile. He doesn't cost nearly the fortune that Xan does (310 vs. 470) and has a shorter cooldown (5 seconds vs 8 seconds). All the makings of an excellent tanking ranger! I am very happy he is joining the free ranger club. I wonder if he will also be available on the spinner for stage clears in the new areas.

While we all wait for Sorcerer Cony to arrive in the mail, Macho Moon will definitely be helpful to those still working on the areas that are currently released in the game. Good luck, everyone!

[Update] Just for fun... Here are my current rollies on the Friendship Gacha. Not great odds. But the 1, 2, and 3 star results are pretty much even.

Sunday, May 11, 2014

Difficult Stages - Stage 108

[Quick Update 5/23/14: Since May 22, many ranger's stats were buffed. There are many ways to clear Stage 108 now, but I would suggest that you invest in Sol as a team member. He is very strong these days, especially maxed out at level 80.

New Stage 108 Video - Easy Mode with just 4 rangers: Sol, Alice, Witch Cony, Warrior Jessica]

Stage 108 is the current end-stage of the release as of this writing on May 11, 2014. It's a very challenging stage if you don't have any special rangers. Then again even if you do, if the special rangers are not KSM or Dancer King Boss, you're going to have to try a few times before you get it.

The very frustrating thing about this stage is that depending on how and when you deploy your rangers, the stage will progress differently for you. The enemy formation varies somewhat inexplicably. I've had situations where in a single stage I have gotten 1.5 Evas, 2 Convini (the best possible formation). Another time I got three Evas, 2 Convini, unicycles and ice cream. Sometimes I get a normal formation of 2 Evas, 2 Convini but with unicycles and ice cream enemies sprinkled in the lineup. Also, depending on where your team is located at the time of Hurry Up, even the formation and types of enemies you receive in the death march of this stage is different. Sometimes you luck out and you only get a sparse lineup of Mabebe, Sena, Tylers, unicycles and ice cream. Sometimes you get your rear end handed to you on a plate by a densely packed stream of more Sena than you can ever defeat along with every other enemy in this zone. Therefore, I cannot really break down the stage into digestible parts. All depends on how you play.

There is hope, however. I found this one video made by a player who has my utmost respect. He not only nailed down the perfect timing for clearing this stage with an all common/free ranger team, he's also figured out how to methodically trigger the ideal enemy formation for 108 (1.5 Eva, 2 Convini, no ice cream/unicycles during regular stage, and the best possible Hurry Up scenario). This video is here, made by YouJJay. *Please* go watch his video if you need help with 108. I'm going to shamelessly take screenshots of his video and discuss them in this post. There are some things he does that I think are genius. Definitely worth pointing out to aid you in success.

The Team & Deployment Order

I'm going to assume that he has at least unlocked the Castle in the Sky treasure, though not sure if 100% or not. His team is probably fully leveled to max and the members are Clara, Alice, Witch Cony, Sol and Warrior Jessica. In his strategy, Warrior Jessica is highest priority for deployment, followed by Sol, Clara, then Alice and Witch Cony. I mentioned before about never being "supply blocked." The idea is, you may deploy anyone who is not on cooldown as long as doing so will not cause you to be unable to deploy Jessica when her cooldown is finished. Example: if you have 500 minerals when Sol's cooldown is almost done while Jessica's is 80% done, don't deploy Sol first. Wait for Jessica's to come off cooldown, deploy her, then deploy Sol when you get enough minerals. Never deploy someone else at the cost of wasting time not deploying Jessica.

Execution

I've tried his strategy several times and it's been foolproof so far. At the start, upgrade minerals to 7, then deploy Jessica. Upgrade minerals to 8, then wait until you can deploy another Jessica, followed by Sol, then Clara. Repeat Jessica, Sol, and Clara again before deploying Alice. Early on, you should only have enough minerals for those 4 anyway, so Witch Cony won't be even a thought until you have a few of those top 4 rangers.

If you time it that way, you will almost always end up in the spot that is identical to the video. Additionally -- and this is key! -- this will allow Convini to walk up *ahead* of Eva and start to hit Sol. This is very important because if he is not at the front of his group, Alice and Witch Cony won't be guaranteed to target him. If you follow this priority of deployment you will trigger Thomas when Convini's health is low and have enough fire power to defeat him before the pack of enemies backs you into your tower.

Once Eva and Tyler start to beat up on your tower, keep deploying your rangers to slow down the HP drain from Tyler. You are required to wait for the 2nd Convini to walk all the way to your tower because you are stalling for time. Time for what? (1) You're feeding your rangers slowly to death a bit here to trigger Thomas later. (2) You need to continue to damage Eva little by little in order to kill her before Hurry Up. (3) You must absolutely not be standing too close to the enemy tower when Hurry Up timer triggers because standing in various locations on the path triggers different formations. Also, standing too close can indirectly make Hurry Up more difficult for you (more on this later).  So, when the tower gets low, use Tower Repair to continue stalling. Use your Missiles as you get them. When Convini reaches your tower, Tornado them both back.

Here's the next critically important thing to note. You need to wait until Convini #2 passes the point where his text box is located before deploying your first Jessica. You need to do this because you want to end up about 1/3 of the way down the road and fight Convini and Eva there. I'll explain why soon.
As you fight Convini, Eva and Tyler here, your rangers are going to very naturally clump up into the great ball of death that you will need in order to slug your way through the Hurry Up part of this stage. If you continue to deploy in the priority mentioned, you should have no trouble getting all these remaining enemies very low. As soon as Hurry Up starts, drop the Meteor on them and Eva, Tyler and Convini will die. Now's also the time to deploy your Friend/Sidekick.

There are 3 reasons you are located here instead of further down the road. The natural instinct is to try to get as close to the enemy tower as possible after a tornado, right? You'll have less distance to have to fight through. But in this case, being far away from the tower gives you 3 advantages. (1) Your 3 heaviest hitting rangers (Sol, Clara, Alice) are very slow. The closer your army's meeting point is to your home tower, the faster and safer you can build up your ball of death army. (2) Convini walks faster than Eva. Giving him time to walk to you will allow you to focus your fire on him alone without taking extra damage from Eva. (3) When the stream of enemies from Hurry Up pop out of the tower, they will be tightly clumped, like their own ball of death. You do not want to be on the receiving end of all of that fire power. Since the enemies all walk at various speeds, the longer they walk, the more spread out they become. By the time you meet them, Sena has fallen behind and you can pick off the lone unicycle very safely. Without danger of being ganged up on, your army will get larger and larger and be able to inch its way to the enemy.

Continue to deploy your rangers, of course, and they will slowly join your mighty ball of death as you push through the enemies. But be mindful that as soon as you reach the tower, one half-health Eva will pop out. Use Ice Shot here to freeze everything in place as you splash down the tower and also kill her. After they thaw, it's pretty much a win!
Ice Shot the 2nd Eva
This method works every time. The timing and positioning are very precise and takes all the guesswork out of the formation of this stage. All kudos go to YouJJay. Go watch his videos, like and subscribe and all that good stuff.

Sounds like updates to the game are coming fast. Hope you guys clear 108 soon!

Saturday, May 10, 2014

Difficult Stages - Stage 100

Clear Stage 100 by May 30, 2014 and you will receive Sorcerer Cony for free in your mailbox on June 5!
This post is just for Stage 100 as it has come to the forefront of players' attention during the Rangers Event Sorcerer Cony giveaway. I've collected all the stuff about this stage and put it all here for reference.

Stage 100 was really difficult and since a couple weeks ago it was tuned down in difficulty, but still pretty challenging for some. Since there has been some back and forth about it with several of my readers, I'm putting all the links I think are useful for people to take into consideration. And these are food for thought only, not an exact guide. Keep in mind, all my videos have the 45% attack bonus from treasures, and I would imagine that the other Youtube video makers do as well. 

Stage 100 is tough on the front line while also delivering tons of very annoying splash damage on your team. It's important to take into consideration the DPS, speed, and cooldown of your available rangers when seeing if they will rise to the challenge of this stage. 

At the start of the stage, as long as you stay on the left half of the pathway and don't cross the midpoint, you will only have to fight a steady release of Tyler (airplane enemy). It's plenty to deal with on its own because when a lot of them stack up, your health rangers will melt in seconds. If you're using any health rangers, make sure that they can be sent out quickly and if they can't (like Styne), you will need a faster ranger to back him up (like Moon). Both direct damage and splash damage rangers are useful in this part of the stage so long as you have someone safely in the back doing it. 

Once you finish off the airplanes and cross the midpoint, you'll start to get Mabebe (chicken enemy) and a lot more ice cream enemies. The thing that's going to determine whether you win this latter part of the stage is the size of your army when you cross the midpoint. If Stage 97, 98 and 99 have taught you anything, it's that you don't cross the midpoint with a skinny army. You need a rather large "ball of death" as you walk across the middle. 
That ice cream is gonna die in about 2 seconds!
The ball of death is when you have a healthy clump of rangers and your entire team approaches the enemy front in tight formation. No super speed rangers are dashing ahead of the group. Your fastest and slowest rangers as well as your melee and long-ranged rangers are standing together pretty closely, all meeting with the enemy together, thus able to start firing on the enemy all at once. Said another way, it's when you build up to critical mass to quickly get rid of the next big enemy in front of you without losing any rangers. Your team will only continue to grow past this point. This is the kind of team formation you need in order for the ice cream enemies to die as soon as they get into damage range. For example, if Xan and Jessica are running ahead halfway across the path to meet a Mabebe and an ice cream alone, they're as good as dead because Ellin/Sol/Alice/Sindy/Clara are way in the back, not even in firing range yet. And by the time they get there, the big meaty health rangers are all about to die, then your long-range team will die too.
Side note: Even the video that uses 2 lowbies has a ball of death. It's the group of Sindys and Claras in the back. 
The entire group moving closely, killing each of the 2nd wave of enemies off one by one and inching forward
This takes a considerable amount of planning when you are fighting Tyler to control how quickly you kill him so that you buy yourself enough time to build your team up while making its way toward the middle. This may mean holding back on Friend, Thomas, Missile and other Items. If you don't have enough total DPS to kill the ice cream as soon as they pop out, you can say goodbye to your army in the second half. I would even go so far as to say, if you are barely making it through the Tyler half of the stage, re-think your team as the second half will surely kill you, and if not, then Hurry Up will. I highly recommend keeping Ice Shot as long as possible so that you can use it to freeze the enemies at the foot of the enemy tower towards the end (or right as Hurry Up begins). 
Hurry up? Who cares, you have the ball of death. Everything melts as it meets with your team. 
The things to pay special attention to whenever you're watching a video of someone's gameplay are:
  • When they upgrade minerals and when they stop
  • When they use Ice Shot and Meteor, and where
  • When do they deploy Friends, if any
  • Which ranger in their team is top priority for deployment, which ranger(s) are deployed only when everything else is on cooldown and you have mineral to spend which will not get in the way of you deploying your top priority ranger when it is ready to deploy again. RTS players will know this phenomenon as not being "supply blocked", thus always able to get what you need most deployed ASAP. 
It's a tough one but by no means impossible. It takes planning, good timing and lots of practice. Hope all these are helpful! Good luck!

Link Type of Review Rangers Used
Line Rangers Stage 100 - General Brown Just Video Sol (70), Clara (60), Warrior Jessica (60), Fighter Moon (60), General Brown (60)
Line Rangers Stage 100 - Xan Just Video Xan (70), Sol (70), Alice (70), Warrior Jessica (60), Ellin (60)
Line Rangers Stage 100 No Health Rangers Annotations Sol (70), Ellin (60), Warrior Jessica (60), Alice (70), Fighter Moon (60)
Line Rangers Stage 100 - Xan, Honey Just Video Xan (70), Honey (58), Alice (62), Warrior Jessica (60), Sol (67)
Line Rangers 100 - 2 lowbies Chinese annotation (Not my video) Sindy (52), Warrior Jessica (40), Clara (60), Rei, Scott
Line Rangers Stage 100 free rangers Not my video Sindy, Ellin, Clara, Styne, Fighter Moon

Videos for other stages in the Castle in the Sky are here.